look, I was a skeptic, but I ended up loving Milk - I love how it disappears into my skin and just makes me smell just a little something special. This is the one I spray every single day, whether on its own or with other perfumes (both dedcool and non-dedcool). I'm tempted to say it doesn't smell like much - but then I'll catch whiffs of it throughout the day and it's SO good when I do. also, whether or not I can always smell it, somehow other people definitely can, and I get tons of comments on how good I smell. (That all being said, Xtra Milk is subtle on its own and is definitely the way to go over Milk, in my opinion!)